FANDOM


  • PROMOTION


    HELLO, DO YOU HAVE A TWITTER ACCOUNT?
    IF YES:

    FOLLOW US: @BlackButlerWiki

    FOLLOW ME: @vualau

    SUBSCRIBE TO MY YOUTUBE CHANNEL, YEAH?

    MY YOUTUBE CHANNEL: MasterLau


    • 🏆 The Best of 2016 Awards nominees are out! Vote for your favorites here! 🏆
    • Click here for an update on BOTA!
    • View the Phantomhive Times issues here!
    • Vote for your favorite administrator here!

    Intro

    I think I speak on behalf of all of us when I say holy shit. Who the hell thought of the Twin-Ciel/2CT Theory first? Because you are amazing and you need to seriously consider solving mysteries for a living.

    Chapter 129: Then what's your real name, Ciel? :(

    This heart-stopping, jaw-dropping, chills-inducing chapter starts off.....rather meh. We have Sie-chan complaining about the rain and Wolfy being one-dimensional as a character as per usual ಥ_ಥ (jfcwhatsthepointofkeepingwolfyaliveandkillingagnihuh). Then Ciel and Sebastian come with an injured Soma, who they leave in Sie-chan's care. Ciel tells her to not open doors for anyone in the future, even if it's him. After that, he and Sebastian head for the Phantomhive manor because there's something Ciel wants to check on.

    Surprisingly, Eddie shows up in the chapter next. And he meets...Freddie. (Eddie and Freddie :D) Apparently, the police has Paula detained, and turns out that Sphere Music Hall has been forcing many women to work there including Paula, which would explain her disappearance. And you would think that you can squeeze out some useful information from Paula...

    Ch129 Paula

    I think this is the first time she had a full-on panel to herself.

    But nooooo. Instead, she bursts into tears and only speaks cryptically, saying that Lizzie has gone to where she belongs. Eddie has no choice but to wait till she calms down, which means we'll have to wait till next month or so for a decent answer. Goddammit. Btw, I wonder how old Paula is.

    Meanwhile, Violet wakes up in a random hospital in Bath. If I had to wake up to that creepy-looking doc, I'd probably scream and fall back asleep, but Violet regains his senses and just when he's about to disclose who the damn Blue Star is, his scene is over.

    Then at the Phantomhive Manor, the servants rush over to greet Ciel. The only one who has a bad feeling about him is Finnian.

    And then we have Soma waking up and weeping about Agni's death, which is so sad. But then his expression changes from sorrow to anger, and he swears to make Agni's killer pay, saying that he knows who that person is.

    Ch129 Soma

    I'm excited for Soma to take action...I really hope he won't get killed in the process...

    We're back at the Phantomhive Manor again. When Ciel and Sebastian enter the place, the servants go to talk to him. I noticed it when Baldie asked Ciel he's out "again in this downpour," and I knew that in the next scene Ciel was going to catch on to that "again" and be all shaken.

    WHAT I DID NOT EXPECT WAS HIS APPEARANCE SO SOON.

    real!Ciel goes down the stairs, and he's all CASUAL about it too, and is like "you'll start coughing again if you're out in the cold" to our!Ciel. Poor our!Ciel (and everyone else) is soooo bewildered and I am too. real!Ciel promises to never leave him again and that he's home.

    Ch129 Real!Ciel

    HOLY
    Ch129 Our!Ciel

    SHIT
    Ch129 Two Ciels

    TWIN-CIEL THEORY CONFIRMED

    Of course, at this point, real!Ciel is the only one yapping because everyone else is too shocked to speak. Well, except Finny boy who calls him an impostor. (Also, Tanaka aka the one who 100% knows about the twin thing is noticeably absent, hmmm...)

    Ch129 Finnian

    It's pretty cool that Finny was able to tell the difference between the two Ciels, but the other servants were disappointing.

    real!Ciel is perfectly chill with the accusation though, saying that he's as real as can be and that the head of the Phantomhive house is actually himself, and in essence exposing our!Ciel as a fake.

    On a side note, can I just say how terrible I feel for our!Ciel? He's so horrified that he's legit trembling. I take back all the bad things I said about him. I just pity him now. Can Sebastian help him pls instead of just standing there.

    Ch129 Ciel shocked

    Poor our!Ciel! What's your real name doe!
    Ch129 Ciel Phantomhive

    Damn. This is an intense cliffhanger.

    Wrap-up

    Dude, real!Ciel creeps me out. He's so damn chill and nonchalant about everything (which makes him sort of similar to Vincent) but the fact that we don't know jack shit about him is what making him so freaky. And I feel like he's out to hurt our!Ciel and yet he's still acting brotherly which is borderline psychopathic.

    Let's see what we know and don't know about real!Ciel so far. He's most likely the Blue Star/Lord Sirius. He's what Blavat and his crew have been trying to revive. Is Undertaker involved? How is real!Ciel's body intact from the fire at the cult? Is he a Bizarre Doll? How's he even functioning - did Undertaker find a way to collect his soul somehow? There's even a theory circulating that the soul in real!Ciel's body right now might be Vincent's or even Cloudia's but I'll hold off judgment on that for now.

    Also he was most likely the guy who held Soma at gunpoint last time. (Who was the knife guy next to him? Did he accompany him to the manor?) He knows that our!Ciel basically stole his birthright and the Phantomhive ring from him so we'll have to see what he plans to do - it's obvious he'll retaliate in some way (technically he already did by killing Agni) but I don't know what else he's going to do.

    But, goddamn, that Twin-Ciel/2CT Theory has been around for years. That person who managed to put together all the clues is a genius, no kidding. I only started looking into this theory a couple of years back, and I was all for it because it was that convincing, but even so, I'm still shocked that it has been confirmed. It always seemed a little distant, but now the twin is right in front of us.

    How will our!Ciel and Sebastian react to this??? And more importantly what in blazes is our!Ciel's real name????? plsdontbealamenameplsdontbealamename I dunno, our!Ciel has always been Ciel to us readers, so I don't know how I'll cope with using an entirely different name for him. Doesn't seem right.

    Oh, and I almost forgot - Lizzie. She probably knows about real!Ciel's existence and that's why she's so conflicted. But then where is she if real!Ciel is here??? And where's Blavat???

    Dammit, we have to wait another month for answers. :(

    Comments on Chapter 129?
     
    76
     
    7
     
    18
     
    22
     

    The poll was created at 02:10 on June 22, 2017, and so far 123 people voted.
    How many SHINING STARS would you give Chapter 129?
     
    91
     
    3
     
    2
     
    0
     
    1
     
    0
     
    3
     
    1
     
    0
     
    4
     

    The poll was created at 01:12 on June 22, 2017, and so far 105 people voted.

    Click to claim your Lau hug!

    Congratulations! You just received a Lau hug. (づ ̄ ³ ̄)づ

     Lau  Talk to me!!  What I do  Lugia  01:12,6/22/2017 

      Loading editor
    • Ok, I'm going to make a comment reaaaal quick here, since I have to dash off to study for my finals AND I WANT TO BE FIRST COMMENTER AGAIN.

      OMG. 2CT IS REAL.

      Like I saw it coming coz Toboso-sensei has been dropping really heavy clues recently (even way back in Emerald Witch Arc) so it didn't come as a complete surprise, BUT STILL THE FACT THAT IT'S BEEN CONFIRMED NOW! AND SO SOON. To think that several chapters back, we weren't able to take this arc really seriously due to the whole boy band thing, but this arc turned out to be crucial to the main plot O____O Actually I was kinda sifting through our old discussions on the wiki and wow this arc has been going on for more than a year now. I still can't believe Emerald Witch Arc spanned two years. But anyways.

      Like I said before, I still don't particularly like the 2CT but since it has been confirmed now, I hope Toboso-sensei will do a good job in addressing the issues surrounding it, which I've mentioned before. For example, why has no one around our!Ciel even mentioned the twin???? Like Tanaka, Madam Red, the Midfords etc.??? If you think about it, by them neglecting to mention the twin, they were actually neglecting to mention our!Ciel (since they evidently think that the Ciel rn is real!Ciel) which is sad. Also, obviously Tanaka was conveniently absent in this chapter because he's the only one in the house that knows about this secret. Or maybe he's up to something. Maybe this is also connected to the Midfords' suspicious silence too, hmmm. Good on Finny to notice the difference between the two Ciels tho, I've always thought he was the closest to our!Ciel :(

      ALSO, wow Soma is ANGRY, which is expected. Nice to know he's determined to do something about Agni's unjustified death (also I noticed you removed the tribute banner for him DDD:). But given that we know 2CT is real, I wonder if Soma is going to have a lot of misplaced hate on our!Ciel (which is likely to be true, urgh). I hope he stays safe - seriously I'm concerned for everyone's wellbeing at this point, lol.

      Tbh, I'm the most worried about our!Ciel. I don't think real!Ciel was actually speaking as a concerned brother - it was more threatening in a way and he most likely thinks all that he's gone through was due to our!Ciel. Real!Ciel is SUCH an enigma exactly like his father. I know Toboso-sensei intended for them to look completely identical coz they're twins but I still feel like real!Ciel bears a greater resemblance to Vincent. THE EYESSS. Also in a side-chapter for Kuro, Vincent did mention that our!Ciel looked more like Rachel.

      Anyways, my comment is super long now and I feel like I have more things to say but I gotta go. Maybe I'll come back to add on more later!

        Loading editor
    • Oh lol, and Sebastian was barely in this chapter, as usual. Tbh, I don't even know if I like him as much as I did before anymore (ik, gasp, WHAT A SHOCKER). Maybe when the plot picks up and he appears more, this will change but I kinda doubt it :')

        Loading editor
    • Oh yeah, I also really want to know our!Ciel's real name. I remember people making crack theories about how Vincent could have named him Earl just because "they can both be Earls this way!", looool. Seems like something he'd do. what if it actually comes true

        Loading editor
    • Tsuminohime wrote:
      Ok, I'm going to make a comment reaaaal quick here, since I have to dash off to study for my finals AND I WANT TO BE FIRST COMMENTER AGAIN.

      OMG. 2CT IS REAL.

      Like I saw it coming coz Toboso-sensei has been dropping really heavy clues recently (even way back in Emerald Witch Arc) so it didn't come as a complete surprise, BUT STILL THE FACT THAT IT'S BEEN CONFIRMED NOW! AND SO SOON. To think that several chapters back, we weren't able to take this arc really seriously due to the whole boy band thing, but this arc turned out to be crucial to the main plot O____O Actually I was kinda sifting through our old discussions on the wiki and wow this arc has been going on for more than a year now. I still can't believe Emerald Witch Arc spanned two years. But anyways.

      Like I said before, I still don't particularly like the 2CT but since it has been confirmed now, I hope Toboso-sensei will do a good job in addressing the issues surrounding it, which I've mentioned before. For example, why has no one around our!Ciel even mentioned the twin???? Like Tanaka, Madam Red, the Midfords etc.??? If you think about it, by them neglecting to mention the twin, they were actually neglecting to mention our!Ciel (since they evidently think that the Ciel rn is real!Ciel) which is sad. Also, obviously Tanaka was conveniently absent in this chapter because he's the only one in the house that knows about this secret. Or maybe he's up to something. Maybe this is also connected to the Midfords' suspicious silence too, hmmm. Good on Finny to notice the difference between the two Ciels tho, I've always thought he was the closest to our!Ciel :(

      ALSO, wow Soma is ANGRY, which is expected. Nice to know he's determined to do something about Agni's unjustified death (also I noticed you removed the tribute banner for him DDD:). But given that we know 2CT is real, I wonder if Soma is going to have a lot of misplaced hate on our!Ciel (which is likely to be true, urgh). I hope he stays safe - seriously I'm concerned for everyone's wellbeing at this point, lol.

      Tbh, I'm the most worried about our!Ciel. I don't think real!Ciel was actually speaking as a concerned brother - it was more threatening in a way and he most likely thinks all that he's gone through was due to our!Ciel. Real!Ciel is SUCH an enigma exactly like his father. I know Toboso-sensei intended for them to look completely identical coz they're twins but I still feel like real!Ciel bears a greater resemblance to Vincent. THE EYESSS. Also in a side-chapter for Kuro, Vincent did mention that our!Ciel looked more like Rachel.

      Anyways, my comment is super long now and I feel like I have more things to say but I gotta go. Maybe I'll come back to add on more later!

      YAY YOU'RE THE FIRST COMMENTER AGAIN!!!! YOU MADE GOOD ON YOUR PROMISE, I'M REWARDING YOU WITH SHILLINGS FOR THAT. GOOD LUCK ON YOUR STUDIES!!!!

      Yeah, who would've thought that THIS is the arc that impacts the plot the most?? Which makes the boy band thing even MORE out of place.....ikr the Emerald Witch arc was looooong. I wonder how long this plot will be.

      Yeah, exactly what we were talking about in the previous chapter's thread! How come no one important/close to the Phantomhives mentioned the twins?? Where is Tanaka, he's my gramps.

      Soma was badass when he was angry, I was like yes! (Yeah, it was time to let of the tribute.....unless you want it back.) Aw, misplaced anger :( But once he sees that there are twins, he'll probably redirect the anger back to the right person...(if he can tell the difference).

      Yeah, exactly, it's obvious real!Ciel's planning to hurt Ciel, but he still dares to be like "oh don't go out in the rain I don't want to see you coughing" blahblah and I was like YOU CREEP. Oh really? I just thought real!Ciel was more like Vincent 'cuz of his aura if you know what I mean, but I never noticed the eyes, thought they were the same as Ciel's.

      HOPE YOU COME BACK SOON!!!

        Loading editor
    • oh wow first time comment here! this chapter was full of surprise and took me a full comeback to this series omg (i mean 2CT CONFIRMED i cant believe the theory even exist since 2014). I had a lot of reading theories in tumblr and something make a lot of sense and i'M JUST SO HAPPY that the plot thickens here (this pattern actually was similar w/ circus arc or weston arc which they use happy tones at first then put the tragedy/angst by the end of the arc although I'm in belief this arc is the longest since the twin finally made an appearance). so funny is that, yana toboso do a boyband tropes but then after exposed sphere music hall suspicious activity the trend it slowly died so ofc that in victorian era no one know what bloody hell is that until we reach 20th century people assume that we innovate boyband thing for the first TIME. 

      OK JOKE ASIDE, I guess so many plot convenient and mystery that being offered in this chapter. I actually do find quite a lot criticism on how the relative never mentioned twins, and in my defense tho since it's about twin death i guess it was kinda traumatizing enough if they mentioned it directly to ciel after he went through hell in the cult in 1 month. (because the relatives themselves barely mentioned rachel and vincent) so I think they know but just keep shut about it. I re-read chapter 10 again when madam red was so hesitant killing ciel (the ciel we know i mean) he just reminded her of rachel. I mean most of the time real!ciel always associated w his father so why in o!ciel case he was being associated w his mom. 

      Tanaka ofc know twins regarding he never call o!ciel directly w his name but always young master. His disappearance in this chapter left me suspicious that is he sided w o!ciel or r!ciel lol. (or maybe he just went to frances place that r!ciel is comeback) frances actually know too but she also just keep silence and let her daughter be his fiancee. (I mean chapter 14 she stated "this is a good opportunity to see what kind of man who going to marry my daughter is") but in lizzy flashback he is already knew and had training with him so why with new observation again. like she even know sebastian trying to hides how their servants were f*cked up their works but later she mentioned it lol. Also I research that child mortality rate in victorian rate was rather sensitive because the risk of dying (the situation because of poverty and security) so parents mentioning the death of a child was rather a sensitive issues too. Beside real!ciel was main mystery for main plot as far as i know because it was rather hinted at chapter 2 so that's why I think it's author trick to play that it is rather useful to reread kuroshitsuji again. 

      Also I was kinda find pretty ironic toward soma when back then he stated "I'm prepared to get hurt and become ciel's agni" but after agni died, guess what he had the same right hand bandaged like agni used before but now.. it seems like he hasn't ready yet.. lolol. 

      Paula is kinda depressing me since she's not telling anything where is elizabeth (aside she said she was in the place where she belongs) it's interesting to see flashback where lizzy had been through after losing r!ciel rather than the past of having fun together with r!ciel. (1st panel she cried found out thinking he may have died as well, 2nd panel refuse to wear high-heeled shoes because she want to stay cute for ciel, 3rd panel basically a preparation to visit ciel like in chapter 2. wow how detailed yana toboso is) kinda like portrayed how she actually had fell in love w o!ciel but also conflicted she should do her duty as queen watchdog's fiancee so that's why she's on r!ciel side?

      My take on this chapter is I do believe undertaker is involved but I don't think he is mastermind (or at least working with bravat) for r!ciel revival. I mean it's kinda OOC to think that he was quite obsessed with phantomhive family (cried over vincent's dead and have claudia mourning locket) then make a surprise attack for o!ciel and killing agni because I feel like it's not his method at all. Undertaker was clearly want to save o!ciel from sebastian (because they basically tied w contract) and don't want o!ciel ended up the same w his predecessor (aka. dying) and stated he dislike queen victoria... wait..... 

      OR QUEEN VICTORIA&JOHN BROWN WERE BEHIND ALL OF THIS AFTER ALL HAHA 

      actually I think this is already quite long so I just end here :'D maybe I'd like to add another theory why queen & john brown was behind all of this but maybe i could be wrong so it's still just speculation. 

      and next chapter if it's start with flashback of r!ciel and o!ciel play together in the past I think i'm going to cry. 

        Loading editor
    • oh wait I think someone had mentioning about undertaker motives on this thread . And I pretty much agree on what s/he said so I'm still in my belief there's no way undertaker mastermind of reviving r!ciel (or maybe backstabbing queen's plan when she make r!ciel(???) drink the poison "sleep a while longer it's still too early for you to wake up"

      explain bravat concern>> "master sirius state has been worsened again" it also maybe because of undertaker's fault lol.

        Loading editor
    • Everyone's so shookt but consider this:

      2DT


      Thank goodness Yana never thought of this. *sighs in relief*

        Loading editor
    • On the real-Ciel being borderline psychopathic... yes I did think he is. But I'm not sure if he really means to harm his brother yet. That scene made me think he's more psycho possessive of his Brother. There have recent talk about 99.5 having clues to the twin theory in the page that shows the playground. But read this chapter then go back and reread it, another pops out right out at you. One spoken clue that plays into what real-Ciel says at the end here. Its when Vincent is talking about fags. He says they are like brothers and tells the son next to him that since he's likely to go to Weston, he'll have a fag.

      Ciel looks really creepy when he declare "I don't need fake brothers". Vincent even paused before reacting there. Now at first I wondered if he was referring to his more sickly brother. But it seemed to me that he is rather possessive of his twin and didn't want anyone to try to take his place.

      They seem to be identical twins, not fraternal, so they are going to look exactly alike in the genetic areas; same color of hair & eyes, ect. But in the ..'environmental factors' is where they can differ. I saw some say real Ciel looks taller. At first, I thought 'how, they are twins!' then I smacked myself remembering how one grows up (who eats more, illness, scars ect) can make one look different. With our-Ciel being a sickly child, its possible the real-Ciel got better nutrition (parents may have fed them but it has to stay down!)so got an inch or two more in height.

      But the eyes looking different? If they are identical twins color and shape should be the same. But emotions! Real-Ciel has the hooded look that Vincent had, he looks like he's smirking all the time. I bet if he stopped smirking he'd had the 'big wide eyes' of our-Ciel.

      Which brings us to how the hell did those three idiotic servants miss a major-in-your-face-clue (Literally!) and not realize something was really wrong.

      When Finny stated he thought something was wrong I had to yell. His Eye, Finny! Our-Ciel wears an eye-patch! For as long as you've worked for him, known him, he had his eye covered! All three of those idiots should have noted that the newcomer did NOT WEAR AN EYEPATCH!

      Which brings us to Soma & Siglinde (sp?). I am hoping Some realizes that his attacker didn't wear an eyepatch and comments on it. I can't remember if he saw the photo or not, if so then he may realize that it was not his/our Ciel, but the other twin, that attacked him. Well if not, I doubt he would be silent and will mention it to Sig. She knows what is behind the eyepatch and would know its not the Ciel they know but another person. After all she knew about the pact and the mark so would know it can't be removed.

        Loading editor
    • ok so yeah even i feel like real!ciel kinda gone nuts in the head ....and tbh i see no difference between those twins if i remember correctly our! ciel when he is in his cold or cruel mode  he looks the same and yes i do see he looks bit like vincent which in my opinion is intention of real! ciel to make it perfectly clear tht he is head of phantomhive......

      and as for y ppl around our! ciel didnt notice the eye patch ...its just my theory but here it is : what if he was wearing an eye patch to fool people around tht would make him more eviler than our ciel! anyway  so yeah what if hes wearing an eyepatch but on wrong eye ?......

      maybe thts wat finny noticed tht eye path was on wrong eye ?

      i mean why finny couldnt point at tht time because he could tell something was odd but couldnt quite tell what ..... i mean there is eye patch but cant really tell tht  its on wrong eye .....idk 

      or maybe he is hiding his eyes i mean our!ciel did hide his eye under tht flower hat once when he dressed as girl..(which was priceless) but rn for me eyepatch on wrong eye is strong point for not noticing tht it was wrong twin....

      well thts wat my theory is i mean ppl arent tht stupid not to miss major thing which even our!ciel  funtom bunny  version  has on his eye XD......or maybe they are '-' who knows....

      and yes i wanna know where tanaka is when u need him .....maybe he gonna appear next chapter explaining where he was in this whole chapter ? and lizzy T-T my heart breaks for her i think she loves our!ciel but feels guilty tht she couldnt tell apart and couldnt help real! ciel when he needed and was all alone T-T i do hope she gets back to our! ciel side believe it or not because of her we see our! ciel more human ,selfless ,lovng and caring side T-T

      she makes him remind tht he has other things to worry beside revenge T-T 

      and tbh i dont think under taker is master mind here i mean yes he has role in this arc but he isnt one pulling strings ....

      to me it looks like queen and UT are having chess match where our !ciel is UT black king while real one is queen white king 

      and queen does know she is playing with powerful person but doesnt know who is he yet 

      and UT is trying to save both of twins .....idk its my opinion and theory :T

        Loading editor
    • Hmmm you've a point that maybe real-Ciel may have wore a fake eyepatch on first meeting the servants so they really didn't notice something wrong.

        Loading editor
    • thank you but its just theory of mine xD i could be wrong '-'

        Loading editor
    • My friends now are like "So I can have the twin, right?" when i'm planing on how to kill them. But still, I don't think I can wait another month for the next chapter, I will be dead already. Yana please upload faster this time ToT!!!

        Loading editor
    • ikr sometimes i wish instead of monthly it should have been weekly T-T

        Loading editor
    • But if it was weekly, she wouldn't have as much time for the wonderful and detailed artwork. I'd rather have it monthly than have any part of story or art suffer from lack of time.

        Loading editor
    • wow ur right but not knowing for month can be deadly x.x for me

        Loading editor
    • Just want to add few things to the discussion.

      1. Sometimes people prefer not to talk about someone someone's lost.

      2. Why nobody saw the difference? IMO, they did! As Lizzy said - what happened to you in one month, she saw he was different but thought it was the influence of that time. And maybe people just didn't know OUR!Ciel well enough to say it's him. And children can chance mentally very fast and especially in those given circumstances. It's not like both boys were standing together for people to watch them and explore the differences.

      And one more important thing. How much of studying one boy could have missed in one month? Well, IMHO, not that much as Sebastian had to teach him. It seems that because of his illness our!Ciel wasn't able to do a lot of things... Who of people around would have thought that ill kid would study so much with help of only one man, his Butler?! Is was more believable that real Ciel has changed!

      Thinking about all chapters knowing that Twin theory is real, I have an impression that our!Ciel was not taken by people around as "real Phantomhive boy". Even real!Ciel in his first appearance tries to low him down. It might be one of the reasons our!Ciel chose to take his brother's name... He didn't want to appear week or it was a "tribute" to his brother, the one he would like to live on and fight. I'm sure both brothers loved each other and one even sold his soul for revenge.

      IMO, both our!Ciel and Sebastian will surprise us at the end!

      The real!Ciel can be not that real but only Undertaker's doings and it will be over in just one arc... or he was THAT important person for whom Gods of death can change their lists and it's going to be a long story. Just maybe real!Ciel is a mastermind behind it all and actually wants Undertaker to get his parents back...

      Whatever it is going to be, something tells me that for our!Ciel it is very real and the most difficult trial from all possible!!! I guess that's the reason why Sebastian is not so active in these chapters, we need to see the struggle that our!Ciel is going trough.

      At the end I think we will see how our!Ciel had to kill the one he sold his soul for himself.

        Loading editor
    • i - for one - am very displeased seeing Soma in such a surge of anger. of course, i understand where he's coming from. it saddens me though, becuase he seems to be falling astray from the path Agni talked about.

      The sun knows not of who is just or unjust. It shines equally upon each man. He who has found himself, is much like the sun.

      this may well signify Soma's true character is now suddenly beginning to deteriorate.

      but anyways, 2CT CONFIRMED!!

      i think the reason real!Ciel looks slightly different is more a choice of aesthetics than anything else. to draw 2 characters identically would be very boring & bland from an artist's perspective i presume.

      as for the eyepatch, very few people actually know about the seal on our!Ciel's eye. to presumably see him without it - exposing an eye exactly the same as the left one - would be the expected outcome, and not something rather alarming. suspicious, perhaps. but not alarming. not to the point where you think you have anyone other than our!Ciel standing in front of you.

      my thoughts, anyways.

        Loading editor
    • This has been the only thing I've been talking about since I've read this Chapter!!

      -=+=-

      The real Ciel should be dead! And also have no soul! No physical body either! But He's alive! And looks hellalotlikevincent!

      We've been shown that bizarre dolls can be animated without a soul from Undertaker's demonstration during the Book of Atlantic arc (I've yet to see the movie, but definitely will be doing so soon). Could the real Ciel have gotten a new soul or did Undertaker or someone using his methods, actually add an extension to his cinematic record? I really do hope it's Undertaker though, he'd make an interesting antagonist.

      I can imagine Undertaker doing things like trying to revive Vincent/real Ciel back, but it makes me curious if he would have known about the fire and kidnappings, and if he knew, why would he be so sad about it? He's a shinigami! A grim reaper! They see people die all the time! They themselves are people who disregarded life and decided to commit suicide! What could have made Undertaker want to bring them to life in the first place! (Could it be Claudia??? >_>)

      -=+=-

      I've also been discussing why Ciel keeps acting so scared. I mean if my dead twin brother came back to haunt me... I mean sure I'd be scared, but if I loved him as much as Ciel probably does, I'd also be pretty happy too? If I was the twin, I'd surely prefer having a "welcome home" instead of being assumed of being a liar.

      It's almost like he was somewhat expecting this and the fear and anxiety of something going to happen is what's causing him to be all scared. You know those times where you're more scared when you know something scary is going to happen than suddenly being surprised? Somehow, our Ciel saw Soma hurt and those words on the wall, and his brain just linked it to the fact that his brother is alive. Suspicious???

      -=+=-

      I also totally agree with about how differently the two present themselves, with one being a lot more taller and smug (very much like Vincent), and the other who looks sad 24/7 with his droopy eyes (who's only been in shock lately, our poor child).

      There's definitely a lot that is shown about the eyes, I simply love how everyone has been drawn. I definitely don't mind waiting a month for this beautiful story unfolding. Anyway, back on topic, our Ciel has really sad eyes that looks like he's seen war and it shows a lot of contrast in comparison to the new real Ciel who's just so confident waltzing in like that.

      -=+=-

      Also can we all agree that real Ciel is so dramatic and so extra?

      I bet he was just waiting for our Ciel to come home.

      He's just standing at the top of the staircase after getting dressed.

      And slowly waits for the best time to come out.

      "Okay so, how do I look ?" (saying this to maybe Tanaka?)

      "Alright coming out in... 3... 2... 1..."

      "I'M HOME!"

        Loading editor
    • MasterLau wrote:

      Oh, and I almost forgot - Lizzie

      Almost? haha... whoops >_>

        Loading editor
    • Monnie0516 wrote:

      Also can we all agree that real Ciel is so dramatic and so extra?

      I bet he was just waiting for our Ciel to come home.

      He's just standing at the top of the staircase after getting dressed.

      And slowly waits for the best time to come out.

      "Okay so, how do I look ?" (saying this to maybe Tanaka?)

      "Alright coming out in... 3... 2... 1..."

      "I'M HOME!"

      ok i find it funny  the way u made real! ciel entrance...now back to tanaka i really wonder where the heck is he, i mean he is only one in the phantomhive mansion to know about twins and when we need him he just poofs ?! .....maybe he went to get his tea =-= i really wanna know where the heck is tht old ninja ex butler when u need him T-T

      i sure hope he makes an entrance in chapter 130 explaining where was he whole time in chapter 129 =-=

        Loading editor
    • There is one thing that still bothers me about the twin Ciels and recent chapters. The photo and our-Ciel's reaction to it. Sure sure some will say he was trying to prevent people from seeing it so they won't figure out there were twins. BUT... remember Ciel's response when he looked at the photo after it fell out of Soma's hand?? He was shocked at seeing it and asked Sebastian if he was lying to him.

      So our-Ciel would already know about his twin, clues seem to say yes, there is no amnesia. So why was he shocked at seeing the photo? What lie was he suspecting Sebastian of telling?

        Loading editor
    • exactly i have been wondering about same thing i mean even agni reaction to photo was kinda weird

      i mean if he saw our!ciel has twin he would have shown sad expression and would have taught tht "no wonder thts y ciel try to hide it and thts y he doesnt talk much about his famliy" ... lets admit it our! ciel barely told them what kind of ppl his famliy were...instead agni gave ahocked expression and also by just looking at the photo how could he be so sure tht soma was in danger and person who was trying to kill him wasnt our! but real! ciel.....i know how u feel

        Loading editor
    • Me and my friends were questioning if Sebastian has the power to manipulate memories.

      What if the reason that no one in the present remembers the twins, but only Ciel Phantomhive because of demonic magic!! That's why Madam Red, Midfords and literally nobody else has mentioned the youngest Phantomhive ever existing outside of flashbacks!

      -=+=-

      Like what if our Ciel has told Sebastian to get rid of all proof that the second Phantomhive child was alive, and possibly wipe all the memories and records. However, physical evidence like Pit's (photographer introduced in chapter 124) photographic plates and photos weren't able to be removed.

      Pit says "I still have the photographic plates, so take as many as you like!", our Ciel clearly reacts with a 'tch!' and an image of Sebby afterwards. Ciel clearly doesn't want him to have those plates, and Sebby is probably involved with those wishes but for some reason is unable to comply.

      So from that, we know that there is photographic proof of both the twins existing but it really is strange that no one else in the present talks about it >3<

      Anyway, the reason he questions Sebastian if he was lying was that our Ciel wanted to know if he really did remove all the evidence that he could or something like that. Seeing that another important thing that shouldn't exist is scary! Sebastian, are you really sure you aren't lying!

      -=+=-

      But anyway, I don't think it's really something in the image but probably something like the date and time probably? I mean when Agni was going through the ashes to look for remaining parts of the photo, he grabbed the corners before immediately knowing something was wrong.

      Since in the corner or like at the bottom of photos is usually where we record dates and locations, could they have been hiding something that can't possibly exist?

      At this point I probably kind of won't be surprised if someone was a time traveller or something. What if the Phantomhives actually existed in a separate time and that's what it says on the photo, but then they shouldn't really exist right now???

      I mean Ronald uses a lawnmower, and Grell uses a chainsaw. It's not like those were found everywhere in Victorian England either.

      -=+=-

      Just when we thought the mystery of the second Twin could explain everything, more and more questions just keep popping up ;-;

        Loading editor
    • om ur theory is good but it gives lot of plot holes like how lizzy found out and how come she believed real! ciel this is so confusing ;-;

      and if sebby was told to make forget howcome baron memories has 2 kids .....i have feeling its something else enitrely......tht photographer get him ! xD

        Loading editor
    • What reason could the so-called real Ciel have to attack Prince Soma and kill Agni? I also believe that the Ciel that we've come to know and love is merely a body double. Think about it, lots of famous people had doubles.

        Loading editor
    • NoMoreVillains wrote:
      What reason could the so-called real Ciel have to attack Prince Soma and kill Agni? I also believe that the Ciel that we've come to know and love is merely a body double. Think about it, lots of famous people had doubles.

      have u read recent chapter ?just curious '-'.....

        Loading editor
    • IMO, whoever got real! Ciel back, he had only one purpose - to emotionally break our! Ciel. I think our! Ciel was asking Sebastian if he told him the truth is about if his brother was dead without return, I guess our! Ciel tried to help his brother but it wasn't possible (as probably Sebastian told him). So with all hints our! Ciel realised that someone brought his brother back to life. That's why his reaction was - that must be a lie. Our! Ciel knows it must be a result of someone's experiment!

      What I'm wondering about is why Sebastian was surprised?! What did he see in that boy?! That he's fake or that he was mistaken and the boy has a soul?

        Loading editor
    • With all the clues, it seems the twin Ciels theory is true and this is real Ciel returning. But a part of wishes it was a demon that took on Ciel's image and impersonating the lost twin..... yeah that's not really likely ;)

        Loading editor
    • I re-read the manga and I still don't know why the so-called real Ciel would try to kill Prince Soma and Agni. Am I missing something?

        Loading editor
    • NoMoreVillains wrote:
      I re-read the manga and I still don't know why the so-called real Ciel would try to kill Prince Soma and Agni. Am I missing something?

      there isnt real reason for him to kill them u know its like put threat and kill some random person who is close to our! ciel just to hurt him ......well thts wat my opinion

      and reason why he wants to hurt our! ciel is unclear at moment it could be anger or entirely something else

        Loading editor
    • XxxfallingstarxxX wrote:
      NoMoreVillains wrote:
      I re-read the manga and I still don't know why the so-called real Ciel would try to kill Prince Soma and Agni. Am I missing something?
      there isnt real reason for him to kill them u know its like put threat and kill some random person who is close to our! ciel just to hurt him ......well thts wat my opinion

      and reason why he wants to hurt our! ciel is unclear at moment it could be anger or entirely something else

      So, the so-called real Ciel really is just another villain with no chance of redemption. Just like Joker, just like Doll, just like Madame Red.

        Loading editor
    • yeah u could say ....

        Loading editor
    • Yeah, the so-called real Ciel is a dead duck.

        Loading editor
    • RIP

        Loading editor
    • It would only make sense. At this point, the so-called real Ciel is essentially the same monster Undertaker became.

        Loading editor
    • u mean shinigami or bizare doll 

      if shinigami ...i dont think so u need to suicide to be one and his eyes were fine he didnt need glasses

      if bizare doll..its possible he became perfect bizare doll

      altho i do disagree on point tht UT was one i mean he might have role in this arc but i dont see him as master mind here well i could be wrong XD

        Loading editor
    • When I say monster, I mean, the so-called real Ciel is just another villain.

        Loading editor
    • NoMoreVillains wrote:
      When I say monster, I mean, the so-called real Ciel is just another villain.

      Honestly, if you think about it, everyone is a villain in another person's story.

      -=+=-

      At this point, we're all pretty sure that the real Ciel isn't an ally, which has been shown at our main protagonist's distaste and death of a lovely person who shouldn't have been killed (rip Agni). I guess we're all just waiting to see which antagonistic role he plays and see if he even survives past this arc.

      It's funny how as soon as I saw the real Ciel, my first thoughts were not only, "yay! two ciels theory is real!" but also "oh he's probably going to die". I'd probably be more surprised if he died this soon though. Killing him right now would've just made his entrance very anticlimactic, and way too fast, as it's right after Agni.

      So I guess that kind of ensures that he'll definitely be a reoccurring character, that's for sure.

      From my understanding, he may be in a similar position as Undertaker (still wondering what they relation might be -3-), where he kind of goes against our Ciel in his own background-y way. I wouldn't come to think that he'd have a situation like Snake's where he starts off as an enemy but eventually turns out to be good. Undertaker is still an overall antagonist as we haven't resolved his story yet, with him escaping from the Campania ship before our Ciel could get to it. I'd imagine the real Ciel may get away as well.

      There sure is a lot of ways that real Ciel could impact the story, but we're pretty sure it's going be a big one x3

      -=+=-

        Loading editor
    • Alliances and loyalties are sure to be tested and/or broken either way. Except Sebastian's. His loyalty is only to our Ciel's.

        Loading editor
    • NoMoreVillains wrote:
      Alliances and loyalties are sure to be tested and/or broken either way. Except Sebastian's. His loyalty is only to our Ciel's.

      Well... More or less the taste of Ciel's soul. Sebastian couldn't probably care less about Ciel if it wasn't for the fact, that this demon is very hungry. It was shown that Sebby would have devoured Ciel if he didn't come back in Chapter 95, well he was about 90% serious about it.

      -=+=-

      Honestly? Our Ciel probably can't trust anyone :(

        Loading editor
    • That would only happen if Ciel (for some reason) gave up on his revenge midway, thus breaking the contract. Besides, back then, it was the only way for Sebastian to snap Ciel out of the trauma caused by the mustard gas. Even if he was 90% about it.

        Loading editor
    • in tht condition ciel pretty much had gave up on revenge in chapter 95 tbh im not big fan of sebby 

      yeah he is good looking no denying but im more attarcted to ciel than him because he is basically the demon who will get ciel soul at end .....which i dont want to happenT-T

      and as for real! ciel yeah he might be recurring character or not who knows but if u have played or seen plot of mother 3 he is most likely recurring character but will die at end when he gets knocked back into senses T-T

      i really wanted our!ciel and real! ciel having happy ending but now our! ciel has to see his brother die again .....as if he wasnt suffering enough the first time real! ciel died.....i really wanna give our! ciel hug (>'w')> he deserves it 

      and i have been thinking on why take "ciel" as name instead of his own ......so heres my theory i can be totally wrong :

      1, i dont think he was jealous of his brother more like his brother was his role model for him hes brother was strong and to over come the fear and to be able to take revenge he chose "ciel"

      2. not to forget tht he has sacrificed his own brother (kinda its not like he had choice) to get one more chance to live as he has stated before "i dont deserve protection" in chapter 92 (i think)he might be implying tht its ciel who was suppose to be alive and remember he is scared to be happy ....wat i mean is he chose "ciel" to constantly remind himself wat he has done and for what purpose he was brought back .........idk i really cant explain my brain in over flowing with theories x.x.......basically he chose name "ciel" to be reminded tht he can never be happy after what he has done .....to the person he cared and cried for....

      and lets be honest i nvr taught our! ciel was jealous of real! ciel......it has plot holes as in if he was only phantomhive to survive automatically everything would have belonged to him no matter even if he was younger twin....there must be very deep and sad reason for him to be "ciel" i kinda feel it ....

        Loading editor
    • As far as anyone is concerned, our Ciel is the only Ciel they know and he's set his image in the London underground.

        Loading editor
    • which makes real! ciel a perfect chess king for queen if she is master mind i mean she knows our! ciel has defied her by not giving her sullin gas

      and if she can replace him with real one, connections would be same but the guard dog will be more trustworthy since he owes queen his second life and might be depended on queen for blood...

      i can be wrong tho....

        Loading editor
    • The so-called real Ciel would still be in danger from Soma, seeking revenge.

        Loading editor
    • Tsuminohime wrote:
      Oh lol, and Sebastian was barely in this chapter, as usual. Tbh, I don't even know if I like him as much as I did before anymore (ik, gasp, WHAT A SHOCKER). Maybe when the plot picks up and he appears more, this will change but I kinda doubt it :')

      Wow, when I responded to your first post, my laptop didn't show me that you posted two more times afterward so I couldn't reply to 'em till now. Anyway OMG TSU DOESN'T LIKE SEBBY ANYMORE??........Jk, I already could tell even without you telling me 'cuz I know you so well. :D

      Tsuminohime wrote:
      Oh yeah, I also really want to know our!Ciel's real name. I remember people making crack theories about how Vincent could have named him Earl just because "they can both be Earls this way!", looool. Seems like something he'd do. what if it actually comes true

      Lol if his name is actually Earl just so they can both be Earls that's funny and also kind of sad.

        Loading editor
    • - Darkchylde wrote: Everyone's so shookt but consider this:

      2DT


      Thank goodness Yana never thought of this. *sighs in relief*

      Holy shit that's so true. (And lol can't believe someone made an account just to hate on the viscount.)

        Loading editor
    • Monnie0516 wrote:

      MasterLau wrote:

      Oh, and I almost forgot - Lizzie

      Almost? haha... whoops >_>

      What?

        Loading editor
    • So, is Soma going to go on a revenge spree?

        Loading editor
    • from the way he said he wants those ppl to pay for what they did to agni T-T seems like they want revenge 

        Loading editor
    • MasterLau wrote:

      - Darkchylde wrote: Everyone's so shookt but consider this:

      2DT


      Thank goodness Yana never thought of this. *sighs in relief*

      Holy shit that's so true. (And lol can't believe someone made an account just to hate on the viscount.)

      I agree it would be nightmare for not only us but also ciel XD ...I dont exactly hate tht guy im more interested in his story to tho ever seince UT saved him in campina .....

      because i doubt he saved viscount for "just laughs" but on other hand UT mind works in weird ways who knows 

        Loading editor
    • So who do you guys think is going to kill the so-called real Ciel first? Our Ciel, Soma, Lizzie or Sebastian? Or do you think he will be spared but never forgiven?

        Loading editor
    • NoMoreVillains wrote:
      So who do you guys think is going to kill the so-called real Ciel first? Our Ciel, Soma, Lizzie or Sebastian? Or do you think he will be spared but never forgiven?

      Not even sure at this moment. But tbh if this so-called Real!ciel like you said killed in front of our ciel kinda bring traumatic moment for him again because he's already being stabbed in the cult. So if he's being killed, just hoping at least not in front of him. 

        Loading editor
    • Am I the only one who considers that our!Ciel may not have a name at all? I know that it's hardly possible but it still bothers me :(

        Loading editor
    • Like I said, our Ciel might just be a body double.

        Loading editor
    • i dont think he is body double .....vincent clearly had two kids ....by this point its obvious and by fact how real! ciel greeted our! ciel he does have a name i just hope its not :alios .....

        Loading editor
    • What if it's Vincent Phantomhive II?

        Loading editor
    • You know a cliffhanger is good when you create an account, just to join in the conversation. Anyway, someone mentioned Ciel's reaction to the photo, which has been bothering me as well. Then it hit me, back then in then people believed that photographs contained a part/fragments of the subjects soul. What if real!Ciel was missing, or somehow changed in the photo? Sebastian is currently the only one we know of, who can manipulate things like that. Hence our!Ciel's questioning Sebastian.

      This of course could bring up another question. Is real!Ciel a Bizarre Doll (sp?) with soul fragments pulled from photographs, or is he somehow a "photocopy" of our!Ciel? I feel like a copy would have also had a contract mark, but you never know.

        Loading editor
    • That's actually pretty good theory. Then somewhere under those clothes the so-called real Ciel must have Frankenstein Monster stitches on his body.

        Loading editor
    • The next chapter came out today and it's confirmed that their mother gave birth to twins. Hint's of this theory came WAY before the Witch arc, in fact looking at Yana's previous artworks, she planned this from the very start!

        Loading editor
    • Oh, dear lord.

      Does it say why he tried to kill Soma and murdered Agni?

        Loading editor
    • NoMoreVillains wrote:
      Oh, dear lord.

      Does it say why he tried to kill Soma and murdered Agni?

      No. The chapter is rather short - it's mostly about Tanaka telling everyone about Vincent's wedding to Rachel and how they had identical twins. No mentions of Soma and, or Agni. (Also, if it was really him is still not confirmed.)

        Loading editor
    • TerriaNight wrote:
      NoMoreVillains wrote:
      Oh, dear lord.

      Does it say why he tried to kill Soma and murdered Agni?

      No. The chapter is rather short - it's mostly about Tanaka telling everyone about Vincent's wedding to Rachel and how they had identical twins. No mentions of Soma and, or Agni. (Also, if it was really him is still not confirmed.)

      Yeah, it's a flashback from Tanaka's POV. It's a very short chapter too.

        Loading editor
    • Define short chapter.

        Loading editor
    • NoMoreVillains wrote:
      Define short chapter.

      It has around 20 pages.

        Loading editor
    • Could someone provide a link?

        Loading editor
    • NoMoreVillains wrote:
      Could someone provide a link?

      It's already up on most reading site now.

        Loading editor
    • Really? I can't find it.

        Loading editor
    • the only thing i've found was a translated summary:

      https://queentheripper.tumblr.com/post/163060811614/kuroshitsuji-130-summary

      help yourselves.

        Loading editor
    •   Loading editor
    • ScarletLycrois wrote:
      Here's the latest chapter: http://kissmanga.com/Manga/Kuroshitsuji/Chapter-130?id=374694

      thank you very much Scarlet!!

        Loading editor
    • The real-Ciel states he is head of Phantomhive. BUT the head of the house is an entitled Earl and it was our-Ciel who presented himself in front of the Queen and was recognized and thus received the title of Earl.

      though of ch 130 it was revealed that its true. The newcomer is the real Ciel and was heir and the one we know was "the spare" (as he called himself). So how will that play out? Will the twin we know and love keep the title of Earl? Or would the Queen state that is the newcomer since he IS the real Ciel and it was "Ciel", no matter who wore the name, who was received the title of Earl?

      And what fo the servants? The Newcomer, real-Ciel, acts as if they are servants of the house (well technically they are) and likely expect they serve him. BUT Sebastian is contracted to our beloved boy (and WHEN are they going to reveal his real name?!) and is loyal to him, not the newcomer. Also it was our boy that with Sebastian went and recruited May-Rin, Badroy, & Finny. Our Ciel asked Snake. As shown way back when Agni (cries) first talked to May-Rin, they have a emotional bond to our boy.

      Tanaka is likely the only one willingly loyal to the real Ciel and that's just out of loyalty to the House of Phantomhive and history of serving their father. He would be loyal to the head, no matter which twin it is.Sebastian is a certainty to stay loyal and still serve our Ciel, but what about the others?
      
        Loading editor
    • So basically, our Ciel erased his brother from history, only to steal his name and continue the Phantomhive legacy he took when he made contact with Sebastian. But why pretend that his brother never existed?

      No doubt loyalties will be tested. Soma's and Lizzy's most of all.

        Loading editor
    • Katzztar wrote:
      The real-Ciel states he is head of Phantomhive. BUT the head of the house is an entitled Earl and it was our-Ciel who presented himself in front of the Queen and was recognized and thus received the title of Earl.

      though of ch 130 it was revealed that its true. The newcomer is the real Ciel and was heir and the one we know was "the spare" (as he called himself). So how will that play out? Will the twin we know and love keep the title of Earl? Or would the Queen state that is the newcomer since he IS the real Ciel and it was "Ciel", no matter who wore the name, who was received the title of Earl?

      And what fo the servants? The Newcomer, real-Ciel, acts as if they are servants of the house (well technically they are) and likely expect they serve him. BUT Sebastian is contracted to our beloved boy (and WHEN are they going to reveal his real name?!) and is loyal to him, not the newcomer. Also it was our boy that with Sebastian went and recruited May-Rin, Badroy, & Finny. Our Ciel asked Snake. As shown way back when Agni (cries) first talked to May-Rin, they have a emotional bond to our boy.

      Tanaka is likely the only one willingly loyal to the real Ciel and that's just out of loyalty to the House of Phantomhive and history of serving their father. He would be loyal to the head, no matter which twin it is.Sebastian is a certainty to stay loyal and still serve our Ciel, but what about the others?
      

      i bet on my life they will be loyal to our!Ciel. those few stooges are literally the *only* love and devotion our!Ciel ever received, aside from Soma and Elizabeth. i think he's aware of that, but gives their affection no value because he saved them from a life of misery. as their lord - their alfa and omgea - he is the only thing those people know and now live for. the love and adoration they have for their saviour was to be expected in his mind, i presume.

      as for Soma and Elizabeth - the way she's been acting lately leads me to believe Elizabeth cared for Ciel more because she thought it was real!Ciel than she actually could bring herself to love the Ciel (our!Ciel) she knows now.

      as far as i can tell, Soma is the ONLY one that so far had very little reason to adore Ciel to the point he does from pretty much the very start, and now that seems to have been taken away from Ciel.

      honestly, i feel like our!Ciel is doing good, but just wants to be loved for what makes him a villain.

        Loading editor
    • also, WTF is up with real!Ciel asking "why the outrageous lie"?

      because everyone likes to be somebody and not somebody's backup persona?

      real!Ciel has the empathy of a potato - which is my first and foremost complaint about him, there's plenty on the list already and he just got to the game which only confirms things will from now on be a ride bumpy as all hell.

        Loading editor
    • Yabucca wrote:
      also, WTF is up with real!Ciel asking "why the outrageous lie"?

      because everyone likes to be somebody and not somebody's backup persona?

      real!Ciel has the empathy of a potato - which is my first and foremost complaint about him, there's plenty on the list already and he just got to the game which only confirms things will from now on be a ride bumpy as all hell.

      Loyalties are sure to be tested. Lizzy's and Soma's most likely. So, who is the real Ciel loyal to then? Undertaker most likely. He does seem to have a connection to the Phantomhive family.

        Loading editor
    • NoMoreVillains wrote:
      So basically, our Ciel erased his brother from history, only to steal his name and continue the Phantomhive legacy he took when he made contact with Sebastian. But why pretend that his brother never existed?

      Actually if you look closely at the series, our Ciel doesn't pretend his brother never existed, he just never mentions it because it was never brought up. Reread the murder arc and the school arc, there's hints that our Ciel was talking about his brother, but because of the context at the time, we readers just didn't link it to his brother!

        Loading editor
    • NoMoreVillains wrote:
      Yabucca wrote:
      also, WTF is up with real!Ciel asking "why the outrageous lie"?

      because everyone likes to be somebody and not somebody's backup persona?

      real!Ciel has the empathy of a potato - which is my first and foremost complaint about him, there's plenty on the list already and he just got to the game which only confirms things will from now on be a ride bumpy as all hell.

      Loyalties are sure to be tested. Lizzy's and Soma's most likely. So, who is the real Ciel loyal to then? Undertaker most likely. He does seem to have a connection to the Phantomhive family.

      i have many thoughts on Undertaker. i don't feel he's entirely behind this, i stated my reasons in a separate post about this.

      we'll see though... i'm becoming far too impatient for chapters with less and less events actually occuring.

        Loading editor
    • Oh.

        Loading editor
    • RIP Fake Ciel. I wonder what is Lizzie doing right now. Is she being violated?

        Loading editor
    • Well, I wouldn't say RIP. I mean, our Ciel is the star of the story.

      I wouldn't say violated. But her loyalty is going to be tested. Is she going to be with our Ciel or the real Ciel?

        Loading editor
    • What i think about chapter 128 to 129

      1 : when ciel asked Sebastian or confirmed with Sebastian he was confirming about recent events like the fact about lizzy words when Sebastian met her in cult i mean he did look quite occupied with those word when Sebastian told him and by seeing pieces of those burned pictures he kinda connected about what was going on ….i mean if he was confirming about his twin death ( his soul eaten by sebby most probably....)wouldnt he look relieved instead of being shocked or terrified at end of chapter ? ( altho im sure they loved it eachother or atleast our! ciel seemed to care about him....but still the life he build up after cult would crumple) It seemed as if his mind clicked by looking at those pictures ……. Or maybe Sebastian discussed about lord sirius room being identical to ciel i mean if we have noticed why cant he ? He may have discussed with ciel at some point right ?

      2: in chapter 129 even before confornting his twin he told Sullivan to not open door even if its him i mean ….if he really was asking about his brother death by questioning Sebastian in previous chapter why would he be asking Sullivan not to open door again ? That doesnt quite add up if he think about the question he asked to Sebastian was related to fact if his brother was dead ….and lets not forget he looked hesitant to go into manor ……he already predicted his brother is on move but he didnt quite think his brother would straight away aim for revealing himself in front of him or every one else

      well i can be wrong tho but after re reading those chapters it seemed more acurrate somehow ?

        Loading editor
    • Who's to say Smile (our Ciel) won't kill Ciel? I mean, the kid basically had Agni killed and obviously manipulated Lizzy. And who's to say Ciel isn't working with Undertaker?

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Shillings to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Shillings to this message

Ad blocker interference detected!


Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.